Remote Blogging: Skoll World Forum 2008 – Replication and Scale

At the recent Skoll World Forum, the Berkeley Bottom Line bloggers covered Dr. Paul Farmer‘s speech following the Replication and Scale session. Diverging from discussions of business models and financial feasibility, Farmer offered a human touch to the idea of social entrepreneurship and scale. They quote from his speech:

Our social entrepreneurs and all its supporters are obsessed with something called scale. The fetishization of scaling up our work is a source of both anxiety and hope. Bringing a new innovative project to scale often feels like the only way to leave a footprint of a good kind in an afflicted world in need of good ideas. . .What’s been shocking to me over the past 25 years is the lightning speed at which policy makers, themselves shielded from the risks [that the poor face], decide that a complex intervention is too difficult or not cost-effective in Haiti or Africa, or not sustainable. In microfinance parlance, many of my patients are “poor credit risks.” But aren’t they the very people we claim to serve in the first place?

This is why I termed my speech a “Loyalist’s critique” of our movement.

We need to be aware that each of the terms and concepts and tools we’ve developed can be used to deny the destitute access to goods and services that sometimes should be rights, not commodities. Does anyone really believe that a mother loves her newborn more if she had to pay some sort of users fee for prenatal or obstetrics care? Such claims are “piffle” as you say in your country. But they are also reflective of an ideology that has crept into our entrepreneur movement. This way of seeing the world has deep, deep roots. It’s been remarked upon already but it’s our culture that is hard to see. It’s our culture that needs to change. Look around you and you’ll see people of every hue but there are not poor people here. It’s not that they need an invitation to Oxford. It’s that they need us to include them in our movement and allow them to be social entrepreneurs.

Farmer reminds the social entrepreneurship world that while scaling can make ideas visible or widespread, we need to remain critical about the motive and means behind scale, and keep the beneficiaries at the center of decision making. All too often, the cost-benefit analyses associated with scale reduces real people into dollar figures.

A NextBillion.net post covers this topic as well, where Moses Lee offers a different definition of scale: “increasing business transactions that positively affect the lives of the poor.” For social entrepreneurs, is scale a business concept or a social and (as Farmer suggests) moral consideration?

This discussion on scale is amidst rapid growth in social innovations around the world, and the question remains on how to maximize impact while staying true to the core of a social mission.

This entry was posted in Primary and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

12 Comments

  1. snizedesk
    Posted November 19, 2008 at 12:35 pm | Permalink

    Hello. It is test.

  2. Posted August 2, 2009 at 9:09 am | Permalink

    Come to aristocrat casino .Links .is focused on .list of casino companies Cool stuff – a search hollywood fl hard rock casino harrah’s casino jobs see In the san ysabel casino mike the mouth poker player image as santa fe hotel casino java poker code the best casino in the world Get info on snoqualmie ridge casino washington .

  3. Botoonedy
    Posted August 15, 2009 at 7:46 am | Permalink

    I just got handsanitizer store from this supplier. They seem to be a great source for any one needing hand sanitizer products.

  4. Posted August 21, 2009 at 9:24 pm | Permalink

    Source about nigerian email letters and discovering around, demonstration of not truth.

  5. Posted August 30, 2009 at 3:26 am | Permalink

    Is not spam, it is only my commercial offer. Sorry if i mistake of topic!

    Buy Clomid – Best testimonials. Buy now. Satisfaction is guaranteed.
    Best price for brand and generic medications.
    From $0.60 per item. Free Airmail shipping for Clomid 100mg 90 tabs and save $135 on order!

  6. Posted October 23, 2009 at 5:01 pm | Permalink

    Good afternoon. google ad sense, How long does it take to receive payment?
    I have adsense Ads on my website but I dont have people click my ad on my blog either. I think ive made about $0.80 this week. Thats pretty bad.

  7. Posted October 31, 2009 at 3:46 am | Permalink

    Сегодня Вы можете без особого труда найти своего друга, подругу, родственника разве совсем других людей, зная лишь номер мобильного телефона!
    Пробуйте =)
    А ведь может вас уже нашли?))))

    Пеленгатор – наш сайт

  8. Posted December 14, 2009 at 1:39 pm | Permalink

    Задумалась о гостинцах на Новый год сыну, ему 3 года, различные-пылесборники-конструкторы у него есть много, он любит мышонка Тич. Я откапала типа такой игрушки, только медведя http://www.sweetwear.ru/1000_b_1.php , кто-нибудь покупал такого? Стоит покупать? Или посоветуйте что-нибудь еще. Не дайте малышу остаться без презента от ДедаМороза.

  9. Posted December 30, 2009 at 12:03 pm | Permalink

    Hey There
    I came across this new online MMOG for kids called Club Penguin. It’s really fun because there are a lot of parties all the time.

    I also came across this site called Club Penguin Cheats Club Penguin Secrets Club Penguin Codes Club Penguin Money Maker Club Penguin Tracker Rockhopper Tracker Aunt Arctic Tracker Sensei Tracker Cadence Tracker Penguin Band Tracker

    Check both of the sites out – they’re cool!

  10. RonAppoign
    Posted December 9, 2010 at 11:49 pm | Permalink

    Antispyware Mushy is froyour same corrupt family members as Antivirus Smooth. These ‘brothers’ in Computer crime do the typical, report fake safety threats, attack your scheme with pop-up warnings, and bog your laptop down. They carry advantage of computer software vulnerabilities and make themselves comfortable deep in the recesses of the system’s challenging drive and registry. The worst case situation from an infection like it is your personalized info stolen by a hacker, and possibly becoming a victim of identification theft. This can be no joke, we have got to obtain rid of Antispyware Mushy prior to it leads to you any headaches.

    This virus is especially bothersome simply because it blocks several of one’s real programs, just like your net browser, and way more importantly, your virus scanner, if you might have 1 put in. Sometimes the only way to get by this really is by operating your personal pc in protected mode and adjusting your method process supervisor.

    But a great question to consider is HOW did you get infected? These viruses squirrel their way into your product by means of the use of Trojans and security holes. Typically by searching a ‘questionable’ internet site without the need of an active virus scanner, the end result might be an unneeded Computer infection. As we’ve by now said, leaving a virus like this to its own strategies can outcome in loss of money or worse, tampering of identification.

    So how do we rid ourselves of Antispyware Smooth?

    If you ever go using the automatic method, it’s pretty very simple. It is what I decide on. But first let’s review the manual system. If you’re a Computer system expert then you are likely to need to delve into your system’s registry and delete all registry values connected using the virus, located in your HKEY_CURRENT_USER folder as well as your HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE folder. Spot out technique recordsdata for example DLL and LNK information having a TSSD filename. Then you are likely to need to destroy the procedure labeled randomtssd.exe and delete any program files and folders together with the title for the virus.

    But like I mentioned – you completely should not attempt a manual elimination if you are not a pro. Why? Simply because a single mistake can render your Computer system unbootable, that will conclusion up costing you a whole lot additional bucks than a piece of application would.

    So having mentioned that, I constantly recommend automated removal. It scans your device, reveals you in which all of the offending programs are hiding, cleans them all out, and most effective of all, protects your Computer against long term virus threats! You may surf the net devoid of stressing about your safety.

    Are you currently drained of worrying about your security and safety? Eliminate Antispyware Smooth before the hackers get to you, and surf the web in peace.

  11. Realny Patsancheg
    Posted April 27, 2011 at 5:42 am | Permalink

    Продажа готового бизнеса. Магазин товаров Секонд Хэнд рядом с метро Озерки (5 минут пешком от метро) на Проспекте просвещения 24/2. Рядом остановка транспорта, большая проходимость. Магазин раскрученный существует уже три года. В магазине есть товарный ассортимент, уличные рекламные вывески. Магазин на сигнализации, полностью обставлен торговым оборудованием. В магазине работает хорошо подобранный персонал. Время работы магазина: без выходных с 11 до 20 часов.

    Площадь магазина 30 кв.м. Расходы на содержание магазина: аренда со всеми расходами в месяц составляет – 56000 руб.

    Цена договорная. В магазине данный момент находится товар около 500-700 кг.

    По вопросам приобретения магазина звоните по телефонам в Санкт-Петербурге: +7 921 570 18 88, +7 (812) 930-56-38

  12. Posted May 5, 2011 at 1:30 pm | Permalink

Post a Comment