| |

[Guest Post]: Financial Literacy and Microfinance – New Research

Editor’s Note: Aparna Dalal works with the Financial Access Initiative, a research consortium between New York University, Harvard, Yale, and Innovations for Poverty Action. FAI is focused on finding answers to how financial services can better meet the needs of poor households. FAI aims to provide rigorous research on the impacts of financial access and on innovative ways to improve access. Aparna previously guest posted on health microinsurance models.

Last week I attended a conference on cutting-edge research in microfinance.  Philanthropy Action live-blog presents in-depth coverage of the entire conference (see posts on Oct 17-18).  Many projects were based in India covering areas like credit, savings, insurance, product design and impact.

One panel revolved around financial literacy and its impact on savings.  With everyone, from the World Bank, to Citigroup, to Freedom from Hunger to IFC talking about financial literacy, it is important to understand what financial literacy really means. Does financial literacy mean teaching someone how to create a budget?  Does it mean teaching someone how to cut back on unnecessary expenses?  Does it mean teaching someone how to compare an interest rate and an APR?  Does it mean teaching someone how to read a rainfall gauge to determine their insurance payout?

The idea of whether the poor need financial literacy has generated considerable debate within the industry.  Muhammad Yunus (and others) argue that poor are good money managers with great financial acumen.  Others argue that the past three decades of experience suggest that education programs could play an important role in helping households better manage their financial lives.  Persistent borrowing, low saving, dealing with frequent emergencies are all indicators of poor financial planning skills – skills that could be improved through well-designed education programs.

It is difficult to tease out the exact effect of these programs, which makes this type of research all the more challenging.  Further, the diverse nature of the programs (as indicated in the questions above) makes understanding the components and structures of the programs critical.


Shital Shah

Shital’s family immigrated from India when she was only four years old, but her heart and soul still remain there. She went on to graduate from Northwestern University and returned to India as an Indicorps fellow. She completed her Master of Public Administration from New York University’s Wagner School of Public Service, specializing in International Development. In the past few years, she has been involved with the Washington Leadership Program, InSPIRE (a summer program for South Asian youth), and internships with Acumen Fund, the UN, Oxfam International, the World Bank, and New Visions for Public Schools. She currently works on savings, technology, and mobile banking projects in South Asia with ShoreBank International.

23 Comments on “[Guest Post]: Financial Literacy and Microfinance – New Research”

  • Santhosh
    27 October, 2008, 18:23

    “Persistent borrowing, low saving, dealing with frequent emergencies are all indicators of poor financial planning skills”

    I don’t see how dealing with frequent emergencies is an indicator of poor financial planning skills. I would think these so-called ‘shocks’ is the fundamental culprit – and not financial illiteracy.

  • Aparna
    28 October, 2008, 9:57

    You are right – in most cases, what is really needed is ways to protect against these shocks.

    My point though was that often in discussions with mfis, I heard that reoccurring expenses that are consistent in their timing and amount (such as school fees) are often thought of as an emergency. These are expenses that theoretically one should be able to plan and save for. However, we see that this is not exactly the case. It is very hard to delineate the exact impact of these shocks vs. lack of planning.

  • 4 November, 2008, 4:57

    In order to increase the access of poort on microfinance, more diversified small scale loan portfolio through rural banking without collateral can be initiated. Monitoring of financial progress of poor is essential.

  • 4 November, 2008, 5:08

    I am interested to attain the seminar on Social Entrepreneurship in India
    along with the gathering of leaders in the social change sector

    4TH – 5TH Dec 2008 at Dakshinachitra, near Chennai, India
    Dr. Narayan Prasad Paudel

  • Sriniwas Kulkarni
    4 November, 2008, 10:56

    I inspired by Grameen system of microfinance. I am 44 , facinated by this approach, to support poor families, to improve their livelihood. I shared with the friends, I am able to mobilise worth of Rs.2 lakhs as initial social capital. This is start up MFI .. working in karnataka dharwad. we supported 40 families.. .
    It is good experience. I want to expand to cover more such families.. I request friends in this blog.. kindly help and guide how to go about …. my e.mail ID: , cell NO;

  • 7 November, 2008, 5:41

    I would like to participate in the conference. Please send me the details.

  • Santhosh
    7 November, 2008, 10:56

    Dear Satish & Dr. Narayan Prasad:

    Details of the information and registration information is available in the below link:
    http://www.unltdindia.org/conference.html

    Please feel free to contact us at if you are having any trouble–

    TCI team

  • subhransu tripathy
    27 August, 2009, 5:12

    Finncial literacy for poor is more about understnding the need of money in emergency periods and schemes/programmes for financial inclusion, micro-insurance, developing saving habits and venues for saving small amounts and exploitations by money lenders, contractors and large farmers and utilising free socio-economic services, basic banking functions and little about protecting their real money wage in the face of inflation. more dvance can include how to restrain them from demostration effects, introduction of production activities involving credits and sources, purpose and criteria for availing loans (micro).

  • tattoomakernews
    30 August, 2009, 14:06

    Hi
    Latest Famous People Tatoos .
    Best tattoos download . amazing tatoos . Where to find ??
    Best and amazing tattoos
    It is sure here

  • 25 December, 2009, 15:55

    Hello! I’m newbie in Internet, can you give me some useful links? I know only about Yahoo

  • 13 February, 2010, 11:17
  • 9 April, 2010, 1:09

    Dear Aparna,
    Most of the Financial Literacy programs in India do not actually achieve the desired results as the underprivileged people do not even understand the basic concepts.The programs are not designed keeping these people in mind.Financial Literacy in India has a long way to go to become a reality. Lots of TALk, Lots of SEMINARS, RBI this, SEBi that, end-of-story. Nothing reaches the common man on the ground because we (individuals, NGOs,etc) are not ready to leave our cosy offices and REACH OUT to the MASSES. I am doing my bit. I gave up a lucrative career in Finance last year to start http://www.SanchayanSociety.org to make School Students Financially Literate.In 7-8 months I have taught more than 3000+ school students about Stock Markets, Global Crisis,Indian Economy, Banking,etc. And I am still committed to the cause.Lets see where this goes.

  • jonnylasanta
    22 April, 2010, 22:27

    buy viagra
    order generic viagra buy generic viagra online
    buy cheap viagra
    buy viagra in australia order tadalafil from us online
    buy sildenafil
    generic viagra online order buy generic viagra
    buy cheap online uk viagra
    cialis buy cialis buy cheap viagra online
    buy viagra now
    sildenafil citrate viagra generic buy tadalafil non prescription
    buy cialis
    buy tadalafil mail order buy cialis now
    buy sildenafil citrate for sale
    generic viagra usa canada best prices order tadalafil by mail online
    buy cheap cialis
    viagra mail order buy generic viagra without prescription
    buy cheap levitra
    buy tadalafil order cialis online

  • 12 November, 2010, 5:22
  • 7 April, 2012, 22:39

    I was recommended this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are incredible! Thanks!

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:29

    sac a main burberry contrefacon,promos sac gerard darelChaussures Pas Cher,Chaussures,Chaussures Femmes,Chaussures Homme Pas Cher

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:30

    vente chaussures gucci prix chaussures gucci homme kawasaki chaussuresurvette et polos lacoste sport 2011,polo lacoste neuf pas cher

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:33

    sac main burberry moins cher,sac a main cuir pas cherair max pour femme,crampon de foot mercurial,homme femme

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:35

    acheter bottes neige discount,bottes kickers,Bottes pour Femmejersey nba wiki,jersey nba uk

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:35

    basket dolce gabbana plaqueBienvenue polo ralph lauren boutique Destockage Bleu Soldes

  • 10 April, 2012, 14:38

    Destockage lot Vestes Ralph Lauren POLO homme noire blanc rougenfl jersey large sizes,nhl jersey cheap

  • 29 April, 2012, 11:46

    Новый стиль – мебель из дерева на заказ : кухни, спальни, лестницы, двери, шкафы

Trackbacks

  1. belstaff jackets} outlet Blog